Should I Hire Someone New or Train My Existing Staff?

As businesses grow, roles rarely stay the same.

Employees take on new responsibilities, customers expect more, projects become larger and supply chains become more complex. Over time, it’s natural for organisations to reach a point where they need additional skills to keep moving forward.

Many employers assume the answer is recruitment. Bringing in someone with more experience can certainly solve the problem in some situations, particularly if you’re creating an entirely new function or need specialist knowledge that doesn’t already exist within the business.

However, recruitment isn’t always the only option, and it isn’t always the most effective one.

Many organisations already have talented employees who understand the business, know the customers and have the potential to take on more responsibility. The challenge isn’t replacing them. It’s giving them the opportunity to develop the knowledge and confidence needed for the next stage of their career.

The most successful businesses tend to build talent from within wherever they can, using recruitment to complement that strategy rather than relying on it.

Start by understanding the skills your business needs

Before deciding whether to recruit or develop existing employees, it’s worth taking a step back and looking at where your organisation is heading.

Perhaps you’re planning to win larger contracts, introduce new services, expand your operations or strengthen your procurement function. Maybe projects are becoming more complex, or managers are taking responsibility for areas they’ve never formally trained in before.

Rather than asking who you need to hire, it’s often more useful to ask what skills your business will need over the next three to five years.

That shift in thinking often changes the conversation completely.

Instead of filling a vacancy, you’re building capability for the future.

At Aspire, that’s where every conversation starts. Before recommending a qualification or apprenticeship, we take the time to understand your organisation, your ambitions and the responsibilities your people are taking on. That allows us to recommend development that genuinely supports the business, whether that’s an apprenticeship, a commercial qualification or a longer-term progression pathway.

Recognise when a role has outgrown the training

One of the most common reasons employers begin recruiting is because an existing role has become more demanding.

Someone who originally joined as a buyer may now be expected to negotiate contracts, manage supplier performance and contribute to strategic planning.

A project coordinator may be responsible for multiple workstreams, larger budgets and stakeholder management across several departments.

An operational manager may suddenly be overseeing change programmes without any formal project management experience.

These aren’t necessarily recruitment issues.

They’re often signs that employees have outgrown the training they’ve previously received.

Professional development helps people grow alongside their role, allowing businesses to retain valuable knowledge while preparing employees for greater responsibility.

Developing procurement capability

Procurement has become a far more strategic function than many organisations realise.

Today’s procurement professionals need to understand supplier relationship management, contract management, commercial negotiation, sustainability, risk management, procurement legislation and business strategy. Those skills aren’t developed overnight, but they can be built through structured professional development.

Aspire supports organisations at every stage of that journey.

For employees starting their procurement career, our Procurement and Supply apprenticeships combine structured learning with practical workplace experience, allowing learners to apply new knowledge immediately within their role.

For experienced professionals looking to deepen their expertise, we deliver commercially funded CIPS qualifications from Levels 2 through to Level 6. These internationally recognised qualifications help individuals develop increasingly strategic procurement knowledge while progressing towards MCIPS, the recognised professional standard within the profession.

Whether you’re introducing procurement into your business for the first time or developing an experienced buyer into a future Procurement Manager, we can help build the capability your organisation needs.

Building stronger project management skills

Many organisations don’t realise they need formal project management until projects begin slipping behind schedule, budgets become harder to manage or communication between teams starts to break down.

As organisations grow, successful project delivery becomes increasingly important.

Developing project management capability gives employees the tools to plan effectively, manage resources, communicate with stakeholders, identify risks and deliver projects with greater confidence.

Aspire offers the Associate Project Manager Apprenticeship alongside APM’s Project Fundamentals Qualification (PFQ) and Project Management Qualification (PMQ). Whether someone is new to project management or looking to strengthen existing knowledge, these programmes help build practical skills that can be applied immediately within the workplace.

Professional development doesn’t look the same for everyone

One of the biggest misconceptions about workforce development is that every employee needs the same type of training.

In reality, every business is different.

Some employees benefit from an apprenticeship because it combines structured learning with practical experience over a longer period. Others already have significant workplace experience and simply need to strengthen their technical knowledge through a commercial qualification.

Aspire delivers both, giving employers the flexibility to choose the development pathway that best suits both the individual and the organisation.

Investing in people creates long-term value

One of the greatest advantages of developing existing employees is that they can begin applying new knowledge almost immediately.

They already understand your organisation, your customers and your ways of working. Professional development builds on that foundation, giving them the confidence and capability to take on greater responsibility while continuing to contribute to the business.

That’s something we’ve seen time and time again.

Manisha Binning completed the Level 4 Procurement and Supply Chain Practitioner Apprenticeship while working at Moat Homes.

“I would 100% recommend the CIPS Procurement and Supply Chain Practitioner (Level 4) Apprenticeship. Since starting my apprenticeship, I have been able to develop my knowledge of procurement and apply this to my projects at work. As a result, I have been able to make a real positive difference at Moat through the procurement of various projects and was promoted to Assistant Procurement Officer.”

Manisha Binning, Moat Homes Ltd

Her experience demonstrates the value of investing in existing employees. Development doesn’t simply benefit the individual. It helps organisations build stronger capability, retain talented people and create clear progression opportunities for the future.

Recruitment and development should work together

This isn’t about choosing one approach over the other.

Successful organisations recruit when they need new expertise, but they also continue investing in the people already within the business.

Professional development reduces reliance on external recruitment, strengthens succession planning and gives employees confidence that they can continue progressing throughout their career.

Over time, businesses build procurement specialists, project managers and future leaders from within while using recruitment to fill genuine skills gaps rather than replace untapped potential.

Why employers choose Aspire

Choosing the right development partner is just as important as choosing the right qualification.

Aspire is a CIPS Centre of Excellence and an APM Accredited Training Provider, supporting employers across procurement, project management and professional development.

Every learner receives dedicated support throughout their programme, while employers benefit from regular progress reviews and ongoing communication to ensure development continues to support business objectives.

Rather than recommending the same solution to every organisation, we take the time to understand your workforce before recommending the most appropriate route. Whether that’s an apprenticeship, a commercial qualification or specialist procurement training, our focus is always on helping employers build the skills they’ll need for the future.

Let’s talk

If you’re considering recruitment because your business needs new skills, it may be worth exploring whether those skills can be developed within your existing team.

We’ll take the time to understand your organisation, discuss your objectives and recommend the most appropriate development pathway, helping you build a workforce that’s ready for whatever comes next.

Call: 0808 231 2477

Email: qualify@cips-training.com

Visit: www.cips-training.com

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it better to recruit someone new or train existing employees?

It depends on the skills your organisation needs. Recruitment is often the right choice when specialist expertise doesn’t exist within the business. If employees already have the potential to grow into new responsibilities, investing in professional development can be a more sustainable long-term solution.

What qualifications can help develop procurement professionals?

Aspire delivers Procurement and Supply apprenticeships alongside commercially funded CIPS qualifications from Levels 2 to 6. These programmes develop procurement knowledge from entry level through to strategic leadership and support progression towards MCIPS.

What project management training does Aspire offer?

We deliver the Associate Project Manager Apprenticeship alongside APM’s Project Fundamentals Qualification (PFQ) and Project Management Qualification (PMQ), helping organisations develop practical project management capability.

Can employees study while continuing to work?

Yes. Our programmes are designed for working professionals, allowing learners to develop new knowledge while applying it directly within their role.

Leave a Comment